2027 Dynasty Superflex Rookie Rankings: Deep QB Class Could Still Be Historic
2027 Rookie Picks Could Save You in Superflex
This could be the year that your QB fates change in superflex if you have a hole at the position.
Many touted 2026 as a potentially generational QB class … but it turned into a dud. Arch Manning and Dante Moore went back to school while Cade Klubnik and Garrett Nussmeier faltered.
Now, 2027 may finally present a strong group.
Manning and Moore are likely to declare this time. Plus, other young QBs offer the potential to be high first-round picks … and fantasy difference makers.
The QBs haven't quite performed up to expectations early in the season, but it still should end up a strong class with four or more QBs selected in the first round.
The class also looks loaded with RBs and WRs who could make instant NFL impacts. We might be heading toward one of the best rookie drafts of the past decade.
Just remember: Things change quickly in college football. Injuries, transfers, and breakout years all shift the dynasty landscape.
We’ll keep updating these 2027 dynasty rookie rankings as players rise and fall. But here’s how things look right now.
TIP
Drafting in a 1-QB format? We've got dynasty rookie rankings for you too.
2027 Superflex Dynasty Rookie Rankings: Top 75
- Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State, WR
- Charlie Becker, Indiana, WR
- Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma State, QB
- Jadan Baugh, Florida, RB
- Darian Mensah, Miami, QB
- Cam Coleman, Texas, WR
- KJ Duff, Rutgers, WR
- Nick Marsh, Indiana, WR
- Kewan Lacy, Ole Miss, RB
- Dante Moore, Oregon, QB
- Trinidad Chambliss, Mississippi, QB
- Jamari Johnson, Oregon, TE
- Trey'Dez Green, LSU, TE
- Reed Harris, Arizona State, WR
- Jackson Harris, LSU, WR
- Deuce Alexander, Ole Miss, WR
- Duce Robinson, Florida State, WR
- Ahmad Hardy, Missouri, RB
- Mark Fletcher, Miami, RB
- CJ Carr, Notre Dame, QB
- Jamal Roberts, Missouri, RB
- Ryan Coleman-Williams, Alabama, WR
- Ryan Wingo, Texas, WR
- Dylan Riley, Boise State, RB
- Austin Simmons, Missouri, QB
- Isaac Brown, Louisville, RB
- Isaiah Sategna III, Oklahoma, WR
- DJ Vonnahme, Iowa, TE
- Arch Manning, Texas, QB
- LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina, QB
- Bryant Wesco, Clemson, WR
- Antwan Raymond, Rutgers, RB
- LJ Martin, BYU, RB
- Wyatt Young, Oklahoma State, WR
- Mario Craver, Texas A&M, WR
- Luke Reynolds, Virginia Tech, TE
- Cameron Dickey, Texas Tech, RB
- Jayden Maiava, USC, QB
- Omarion Miller, Arizona State, WR
- Raleek Brown, Texas, RB
- Terrance Carter, Texas Tech, TE
- Nate Frazier, Georgia, RB
- Connor Weigman, Houston, QB
- TJ Moore, Clemson, WR
- Amare Thomas, Houston, WR
- Cam Cook, West Virginia, RB
- Wayne Knight, UCLA, RB
- Waymond Jordan, USC, RB
- Brendan Sorsby, Texas Tech, QB
- DeSean Bishop, Tennessee, RB
- Junior Sherrill, Vanderbilt, WR
- Julian Sayin, Ohio State, QB
- Nyck Harbor, South Carolina, WR
- Rocky Beers, Oklahoma, TE
- Hollywood Smothers, Texas, RB
- Mike Matthews, Tennessee, WR
- Chris Marshall, Arkansas, WR
- Justice Haynes, Georgia Tech, RB
- Beau Sparks, Texas State, WR
- Justin Bowick, Oklahoma State, WR
- Fluff Bothwell, Mississippi State, RB
- Benjamin Brahmer, Penn State, TE
- Cooper Barkate, Miami, WR
- CJ Bailey, NC State, QB
- CJ Baxter, Kentucky, RB
- Kamari Moulton, Iowa, RB
- Sam Leavitt, LSU, QB
- Easton Messer, FIU, WR
- Giovanni Lopez, Wake Forest, QB
- Micahi Danzy, Florida State, WR
- Jahiem White, North Texas, RB
- Braylon Staley, Tennessee, WR
- Dorian Thomas, TE, Cal
- Keyjuan Brown, Louisville, RB
- Kenny Johnson, Texas Tech, WR
New Top Contenders Enter The Conversation
The expectation heading into the season was that Arch Manning and Dante Moore would battle for the top QB spot. Both have fallen short though. Manning continues struggling with turnovers while Moore suffered a severe concussion, ending his season.
Both could still be first round picks, but new names have emerged as candidates for the first QB taken.
Oklahoma State’s Drew Mestemaker currently is the favorite. The 6’3, 215 pound QB followed HC Eric Morris from North Texas to the Cowboys. He shows high end processing going through progressions to find the perfect WR to target.
Mestemaker has the zip and arm strength to be a franchise QB, along with the ability to scramble for big gains.
Experience will be the downside of Mestemaker. He was only the back-up QB in high school, playing Safety and Punter. He walked onto North Texas and rose his way to becoming the starter before the First Responders Bowl after the 2024 season.
He showed promise in 2025 at North Texas and now has exploded as a legit NFL prospect at Oklahoma State. Mestemaker has top-10 NFL QB upside, but lack of high-end competition along with the experience issue is concerning.
Another Miami QB at the Top?
The other contender for top QB is Miami’s Darian Mensah. He came to the Hurricanes from Duke, where he threw for 3,973 yards and 34 TDs. He is on pace to crush those numbers at Miami.
Mensah certainly has better weapons now with star WR Malachi Toney and they also brought over WR Cooper Barkate from Duke to stick with Mensah.
Mensah’s ceiling may be a Brock Purdy type of QB who wins more with smart decisions and accuracy than putting the ball ito tight spaces or throwing down field. He lacks the ideal upside, but could have fantasy success with the right system and weapons.
The First Round Could be Filled with QBs
There is a wide net for other potential QBs in Round 1. Manning and Moore certainly can still be selected there if they declare.
Ole Miss QB Trinidad Chambliss obliterated LSU this season, likely locking himself into the first round. He threw for 363 yards and 2 TDs while rushing for another. Chambliss' impressive arm strength and decision making pushed him to gain national recognition.
The drawback for Chambliss? He stands just below 6'0 tall (as verified in the spring by BLESTO), and around 200 pounds. Plus, he will be 25-years old before his first NFL snap.
NFL teams will have to decide how that affects Chambliss' stock.
Notre Dame’s CJ Carr and Missouri’s Austin Simmons are worth monitoring as well. Both have NFL style highlights, fitting the ball into tight spaces against good defenses. Both still need some development and could return to school, but they are in the first round conversation.
Sellers and Sorsby: Two Different Bets
Several other QBs could play their way to the top of the 2027 Draft.
South Carolina’s LaNorris Sellers has never quite lived up to expectations, but the upside is tremendous. At 6’3, 240 pounds with a projected 40 time in the mid-4.5 range, he brings Anthony Richardson-like traits with three years of starting experience.
Sellers’ size, rushing upside, and rocket arm give him top-5 fantasy upside if he develops into an NFL starter.
You probably know Brendan Sorsby’s story by now. He was ruled ineligible after evidence surfaced that he gambled on his own team while redshirting at Indiana. The NFL also declined to hold a supplemental draft, so Sorsby will spend a year away from football before becoming eligible in 2027.
Sorsby’s highlights are among the best in the class, but his inconsistency makes him tough to evaluate. He probably lands on Day 2 or early Day 3, though the off-field issues and year away from football could push him further down the board.
Jayden Maiava, Connor Weigman, and Sam Leavitt could also play their way into first-round consideration.
These 2027 Dynasty Superflex Rookie Rankings Are Just The Start
Let Us Help You Win ... Year After Year
Don't you want your dynasty fantasy football team to compete every year — so that you never have to go into rebuilding mode? Our Dynasty Playbook is designed to help you do just that.
Check out the video below to learn more about the powerful tools that will help ...
